Here are the top five lesser-known Tudor romance scandals:
5. The tragic story of Katherine Howard, Henry VIII’s young and vivacious fifth wife, is one such narrative that underscores the perilous intersection of love and ambition in Tudor England. Thrust into the limelight as queen when she was still a teenager, Katherine’s past and clandestine liaison quickly became the fodder for courtly intrigue.
Before her marriage to Henry, Katherine’s romantic entanglements, notably with Henry Mannox and Frances Dereham, were whispered secrets that she hoped were buried in her past. However, it was her alleged affair with Thomas Culpepper, a close courtier of the king, that ignited a scandal with fatal consequences.
The discovery of Katherine’s indiscretions, real or fabricated, set a tragic end in motion. Katherine, accused of treason for her premarital relationships and the affair with Culpepper. Katherine’s fate was sealed in a public spectacle of disgrace and punishment.
Her story not only highlights the dangers that young women in the Tudor court faced, but also reflects the broader themes of power, control, and the perilous politics of the royal bedchamber. Katherine Howard’s life, shrouded in scandal, serves as a poignant prologue for the tales of intrigue that simmered beneath the surface of Tudor grandeur.
4. Katherine Parr and Thomas Seymour. The widowhood of Katherine Parr, the sixth and surviving wife of Henry VIII, took a scandalous turn with her hasty marriage to Thomas Seymour, the Lord High Admiral and brother of Henry’s third wife, Jane Seymour.
Mere months after the King’s death in 1547, Katherine, who had been a calming and reformist influence on Henry, entered into a union that sent shockwaves through the Tudor court. Seymour, known for his ambition and charm, was also the uncle of the young Edward VI, positioning him close to the center of power, a fact that made their marriage all the more contentious.
The marriage raised eyebrows not only because of its rapid timing, but also due to Seymour’s well-known aspirations to increase his influence. Katherine’s position as the Dowager Queen and her close relationship with the young Princess Elizabeth, who resided in their household, adds layers of complexity and intrigue to their union.
Seymour’s subsequent actions, including flirtations with Elizabeth and a bold but ill-fated bid for power, only served to deepen the scandal. The repercussion of Katherine and Seymour’s marriage were far-reaching, affecting court politics and the intricate web of Tudor succession.
Seymour’s eventual arrest and execution for treason underscored the volatile nature of Tudor alliances and the dangerous interplay between personal ambition and the machinations of power. Their story is a testament to the unpredictable dynamics of the Tudor court, where love, ambition, and treachery were often closely intertwined.
3. The Dudley love triangle involving Robert Dudley, Amy Robsart, and Queen Elizabeth I remains one of the Tudor period’s most enigmatic scandals shrouded in mystery and speculation. Robert Dudley, a favorite of Elizabeth I and a key figure at her court, found his life and ambitions irrevocably altered by the tragic and untimely death of his wife Amy in 1560.
Amy Robsart’s demise under suspicious circumstances with a fetal fall down a staircase at Cumnor Place in Oxfordshire ignited a firestorm of rumors that implicated Dudley in a dark plot to free himself from his marriage, thereby paving the way for a union with the Queen. The scandal surrounding Amy’s death cast a long shadow over Dudley’s reputation and his relationship with Elizabeth.
Despite the Queen’s evident fondness for Dudley, highlighted by their close companionship and the lavish attention she bestowed upon him, The whispers of foul play and ambition made any prospect of marriage politically toxic. The court and the public alike were rife with gossip and speculation, which threatened not only Dudley’s position, but also the Queen’s image as a virtuous and just monarch.
Elizabeth, acutely aware of the delicate balance of public opinion and the need to maintain her authority unblemished, navigated the scandal with her characteristic prudence. Although Dudley remained a prominent courtier and was later made Earl of Leicester, the stain of the scandal effectively barred him from ever becoming consort.
The Dudley love triangle thus exemplifies the intricate interplay of personal relationships and public perceptions in the Tudor court, where love, ambition, and tragedy were inextricably linked with profound implications for those involved and the course of Elizabeth’s reign.
2. The affair between Anne Vavasour and the Earl of Oxford, Edward De Vere. So Anne Vavasour was a young maid-of-honor to Elizabeth I. Anne had an affair with Edward De Vere, 17th Earl of Oxford, which stands out for its dramatic intensity and the scandal it caused.
The clandestine relationship, blooming within the confines of Elizabeth’s court, broke the conventions of the time and led to one of the most sensational scandals of the Elizabethan era. The affair came to light in 1581, when Anne gave birth to De Vere’s illegitimate son, a revelation that shocked the court and infuriated Queen Elizabeth, who had strict rules against such liaisons among her courtiers.
The Queen’s response was swift and severe. Both Anne and De Vere were imprisoned in the Tower of London for their indiscretion, a punishment that underscored the gravity of their offense in the Queen’s eyes. The scandal did not end with their imprisonment. Upon their release, the affair led to a series of violent confrontations, fueling a bitter feud between De Vere and Anne’s kinsmen. The most notable incident was a deadly duel in the streets of London, which resulted in several injuries and further deepened the animosity between the two factions.
This series of events not only highlighted the personal risks of such romantic entanglements, but also reflected the broader tensions within the Elizabethan court, where honor, reputation, and loyalty were constantly at stake. The affair of Anne Vavasour and Edward De Vere with its blend of passion, defiance, and tragedy, exemplifies the complex interplay of personal desires and societal constraints in Tudor England.
1. The Frances Howard and Robert Carr scandal, which culminated in the mysterious death of Thomas Overbury, stands as one of the most sordid tales of the early Stuart period, intertwining love, ambition, and murder at the highest levels of English society.
Frances Howard was initially married to the Earl of Essex and sought an annulment to wed Robert Carr, Earl of Somerset, and a favorite of King James I. The annulment, granted under scandalous circumstances, was just the beginning of a saga that would shock the nation.
The union between Howard and Carr was marred by the shadow of Thomas Overbury, a close advisor and friend to Carr, who vehemently opposed their relationship. Overbury’s subsequent imprisonment in the Tower of London and mysterious death in 1613, later revealed to be poison, ignited a firestorm of rumors and accusations.
The investigation unveiled a complex web of intrigue implicating not only Frances and Carr, but also members of their inner circle in a murder plot. The trial that followed was a public spectacle, drawing attention to the corrupt and decadent nature of James I’s court.
Frances and Carr were both found guilty, the images tarred, and their positions at court irreparably damaged. The overbearing scandal exposed the dark underbelly of Jacobean politics and courtly intrigue, highlighting the lengths to which individuals would go for love and power. The public outcry and fascination with the case underscored the perennial allure of scandal and the dangerous intersection of personal desires with political machinations.
The Tudor and Stuart periods were rife with romantic intrigue where love often collided with ambition. Leading to scandals that echoed through the annals of history. These tales of passion, betrayal, and intrigue offer a window into the complex interplay of personal desires and political power.
Heather Teysko is the creator, writer, and producer of The Renaissance English History Podcast,  the original Tudor history podcast, started in 2009. She's been writing about history online for over 25 years, since her first site on Colonial American history became number one in history on Yahoo in 1998. In 2019 she created Tudorcon, which is now a yearly event, in addition to writing books, and running TudorFair.com - a whimsical Tudor Merch shop.
She has been passionate about Tudor England since she first read Alison Weir's The Six Wives of Henry VIII 30 years ago, and subsequently moved to London after college to spend her time immersed in Tudor history (how exciting when she got to interview Alison for the first time!). In addition to history, she is passionate about travel, and has lived in 3 countries and 4 states (not counting her perpetual state of confusion), and her family (who help her host her YouTube channel occasionally).
